Is Fan Fiction the Devil (or am I overreacting)?

So, a couple of days ago, I got an email with this little story in it from GalleyCat, about a book deal worth seven figures for a work that started out as Twilight fan fiction (Gabriel’s Inferno and Gabriel’s Rapture, by Sylvain Reynard). And no, I’m not talking about Fifty Shades of Grey. If you haven’t heard about Fifty Shades of Grey (by E L James), where the heck have you been for the past few months? It also started out as a Twilight fan fiction piece, albeit one of erotica.

However, these two works of fan fiction are not your usual, run-of-the-mill, only-read-by-fans-on-some-website fan fiction. Fifty Shades of Grey has been phenomenally successful. According to Wikipedia, “On 1 August 2012, announced that they had sold more copies of Fifty Shades of Grey than they had of the entire Harry Potter series combined, making E. L. James their best-selling author ever, overtaking J.K. Rowling.” And according to Reynard’s blog yesterday, Gabriel’s Inferno is #35 on the New York Times Bestsellers List (Ebook/Fiction).

My initial reaction to these two pieces of information isn’t exactly printable, but it amounts to something along the lines of “Are you freaking kidding me?!” Fan fiction is, by definition (again, Wikipedia), “fan labor regarding stories about characters or settings written by fans of the original work, rather than by the original creator.” So, these two writers were such huge fans of the Twilight series and its characters that they went out and wrote their own stories about these characters/this world.

Okay. I can understand that. I understand loving characters and a world so much that you just can’t bear to let them go. I love The Dragonriders of Pern. I have no idea how many times I’ve read that series and wished I could be a dragonrider. I can’t even put into words how much I love Gone with the Wind (and for the record, I’ve read that something like upwards of 20 times). Scarlett kicks a**, even if she is kind of clueless sometimes and makes me a little angry (Yes, I still get mad every time I read that book. Who in their right mind would want Ashley when Rhett is right there?). But I’ve never written any sort of re-telling of the story, or written my preferred version of what happened between them.

So, again, are you kidding me? Don’t get me wrong: I firmly believe every writer has the right to write whatever they want, whatever moves them, no matter what anyone else thinks of it. But it bothers me that these two authors are making a substantial amount of money off of works that are based on someone else’s creation. Maybe they changed the names/locations/plots to distance themselves. Maybe the books, in their current incarnations, aren’t anything remotely similar to their original versions (I really can’t say. Apart from the brief bits in the GalleyCat links above, I haven’t read either of them.). Maybe these authors were so inspired by Twilight that they realized their dreams of writing a novel. However….

Writing something based on someone else’s creation would feel like stealing to me. On a personal level, I couldn’t do it. Writing a piece of fan fiction strictly for yourself is one thing. Writing it and putting it out there for others to read, even if it’s made clear that it is based on someone else’s work, is another. Yes, maybe imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, but still, you took someone else’s work, changed it up, and called it your own. I read Eragon, too, and it’s similarities to Lord of the Rings and Star Wars bothered me immensely, so maybe this is my own personal problem, but what does everyone else think about this?

/end rant

4 thoughts on “Is Fan Fiction the Devil (or am I overreacting)?

  1. Really enjoyed this piece and yes, I do agree that fan fiction is problematic. Take Amanda Hockings, Tryll books. Definitely based on Twilight, with characters I wanted to strangle. The Witches one, I forget it’s full title. Based on Twilight for grown ups……. Now, I enjoyed Twilight don’t get me wrong but can we have a different story now? Personally, I blame Disney…. That’s what these stories are, really, Disney princess and prince stories.


    1. Thanks for the comment….I haven’t actually read the Hocking books, but my mother *just* brought them for me to read (just as in she just came to town two days ago), so I guess I’ll have to give the first one a shot and see what I think…blame it on Disney. I like that. Good point. I like a happily-ever-after as much as the next person, but realistically, it doesn’t always happen.


      1. Ohhh sorry if you haven’t read the books.. You might like them? There were lots of good reviews too. It just felt very formulaic for me.

        I love happy ever afters and I am writing a story with a happy ever after too. I just don’t want the way we get to the story HEA, to be the same every time.

        Normal Girl (who discovers they are not normal has special power of some sort) meets mysterious prince (insert vampire, tryll, werewolf) swoons, lot’s of repressed sexual tension and they then live happily ever after.

        On Twilight, have you read Host? Much, much, much better and clever. Stick with it through the first 100 pages (think the editor must have been on holiday) and it rocks!


      2. At the very least, I’ll give them a shot. I do like HEA’s, but I don’t tend to use that particular formula when I write. It works for some , just not me.

        I HAVE read the Host. I enjoyed it much more than Twilight, although you’re right: that first bit was a little rough to slog through. I’m interested to see how they turned it into a movie next year.


Leave a Reply to tamaramorning Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.